Lead Pulling - Why Collars and Harnesses Aren’t Enough

Loose-Lead Walking: Why Equipment Alone Won’t Stop Your Dog from Pulling

Do you wonder “What is the best type of collar to stop pulling?” or “What is the best type of dog harness to stop pulling?”?

Walking your dog should be a relaxing and enjoyable experience, but for many dog owners, it can be a stressful and frustrating ordeal when their dog constantly pulls on the lead. If you find yourself being dragged down the street by your eager canine companion, you’re not alone. While there are various collars and harnesses on the market that promise to reduce pulling on the lead, it's important to understand that these tools alone won’t solve the problem. The real solution lies in training your dog to choose not to pull, transforming your walks into a calm and enjoyable activity for both of you. 

Understanding the Impact of Painful Collars

There are collars designed to reduce pulling by applying discomfort or pain, such as choke chains, prong collars, and shock collars. While these devices may work in the short term by causing your dog to associate pulling with an unpleasant sensation, they don’t teach your dog why they shouldn’t pull or how to enjoy a loose-lead walk. Instead, they rely on fear or discomfort to suppress the behaviour, which can lead to increased anxiety, fear, and even aggression in some dogs.

Painful collars might stop your dog from pulling temporarily, but they don’t address the root cause of the behaviour. Dogs pull because they are excited, curious, or simply haven’t learned how to walk nicely on a lead. The goal should be to teach your dog to walk calmly by your side—not out of fear of pain, but because they understand and enjoy the behaviour. I do, however, recommend using a comfortable, no-escape collar while lead training.

The Role of Training in Loose-Lead Walking

Training is the most effective way to stop your dog from pulling on the lead. By teaching your dog to choose to walk beside you, you create a positive experience for both of you. Training allows you to communicate with your dog, build a strong bond, and encourage good behaviour through understanding rather than force. 

Using a Front-Clip Harness: A Helpful Tool, Not a Solution

While training is essential, using the right equipment can aid in the process—especially during the initial stages. A front-clip harness is an excellent tool for reducing pulling. Unlike collars that apply pressure to your dog’s neck, a front-clip harness attaches to the lead at the front of the chest, helping to redirect your dog’s momentum and making it more difficult for them to pull forward.

When using a front-clip harness, it’s important to ensure that the clip is positioned high on your dog’s chest. This helps to avoid putting unnecessary strain on their shoulders and joints, which can occur if the harness is too low. The front-clip harness is a great tool to use in combination with training, as it offers a gentle way to guide your dog while still allowing you to work on teaching them loose-lead walking. 

The Power of Positive Reinforcement

Positive reinforcement is one of the most effective methods for teaching your dog to stop pulling on the lead. This training technique involves rewarding your dog for the behaviours you want to encourage, such as walking calmly by your side. By consistently rewarding your dog when they make the right choice, you reinforce the behaviour, making it more likely that they will repeat it in the future. 

Steps to Teach Your Dog to Stop Pulling Using Positive Reinforcement:

• Start with the Right Equipment: Use a standard lead (6 feet) and a front-clip harness. Avoid retractable leads, as they can encourage pulling.

• Begin in a Low-Distraction Environment: Start training in a quiet area where your dog is less likely to be distracted. This could be your garden or a quiet park.

• Reward for Eye Contact: Stand still and wait for your dog to look at you. When they do, immediately reward them with a treat. This teaches your dog to pay attention to you.

• Practise ‘Heel’ or Walking by Your Side: Once your dog is focused on you, take a few steps forward. If they stay by your side without pulling, reward them with a treat. If they pull, stop walking and wait for them to return to your side before continuing.

• Use a Cue Word: As your dog begins to understand the concept of walking beside you, introduce a cue word like “heel” or “let’s go.” Use this word just before you start walking, and reward your dog for staying by your side.

• Gradually Increase Distractions: As your dog becomes more consistent, gradually increase the level of distraction. Practise in different locations, slowly building up to more challenging environments.

• Be Patient and Consistent: Training takes time and consistency. Practise regularly, and always reward your dog for making the right choices. 

The Benefits of Positive Reinforcement Training

Positive reinforcement not only helps to stop your dog from pulling but also strengthens the bond between you and your dog. It encourages trust and cooperation, leading to a more enjoyable and stress-free walking experience. Dogs trained with positive methods are often more confident and happier because they are motivated by rewards rather than fear of punishment.

Conclusion: Training is the Ultimate Solution

While collars and harnesses can be helpful in aiding and managing lead pulling, they should not be relied upon as the sole solution. Using a prong collar for lead training might suppress the behaviour temporarily, but it won’t teach your dog to enjoy walking by your side. A front-clip harness for lead pulling is a useful tool, but it should be used in conjunction with training, not as a replacement for it.

The best way to stop your dog from pulling on the lead is through consistent, positive reinforcement training. By teaching your dog to choose to walk calmly by your side, you’ll create a positive and enjoyable experience for both of you. With patience, consistency, and the right techniques, you can transform your walks into a peaceful and pleasant activity that you and your dog look forward to every day.

Effective Lead Training Tips from a South Ayrshire Dog Trainer: Why Collars and Harnesses Aren’t Enough

When it comes to managing lead pulling, collars and harnesses can be useful tools, but they shouldn’t be your only strategy—especially for dog owners in South Ayrshire and surrounding areas. For example, using a prong collar for lead training may temporarily suppress pulling, but it does not teach your dog to enjoy walking calmly by your side.

A front-clip harness for lead pulling can help reduce pulling by redirecting your dog’s movement, but it must be paired with proper training rather than used as a standalone fix.

The most effective way to stop your dog pulling on the lead is through consistent, positive reinforcement training tailored to your dog’s needs. By teaching your dog in South Ayrshire to walk politely and calmly on the lead, you create a stress-free, enjoyable experience for both of you.

With patience, consistency, and the right guidance from a professional dog trainer in South Ayrshire, your daily walks can become peaceful, rewarding times that strengthen your bond and keep your dog happy and well-behaved.

📍 Scotland Dog Training in Based in Ayr, Scotland and provides Dog Behaviour Training in Maybole, Girvan, Ayr and surrounding communities in South Ayrshire. Effective Lead Training Tips from a South Ayrshire Dog Trainer
📬 Get in touch for support with dog behaviour, introductions, and positive training. 

Dog pulling on lead training South Ayrshire, Loose lead walking South Ayrshire, Stop dog pulling Ayrshire, Lead training for dogs South Ayrshire, Dog trainer lead pulling Ayr Scotland, Dog walking training Maybole Girvan Ayr